Did You Know You're Being Upsold in the Emergency Room?

What hospitals don't want you to know about the people pushing carts through your medical records

You walk into the emergency room with a sprained ankle. The familiar chaos surrounds you – beeping monitors, rushing nurses, the physician taking your history and ordering an X-ray.

What you don't see is the person in scrubs pushing a cart, quietly reviewing your chart 24 hours later.

Their job? Finding reasons to change your Level 2 emergency visit into a Level 4 — increasing your facility fee from roughly $200 to about $450 (Medicare; commercial is often much higher). This is separate from the clinician's professional fee.

Welcome to the world of coding consultants – healthcare's multi-billion-dollar optimization industry disguised as "better documentation."

As someone who has led healthcare organizations through digital transformations and witnessed this evolution firsthand, I can tell you this: the emergency room coding industry has become a sophisticated revenue extraction machine that prioritizes profit over patient care.

And here's what should terrify every patient: artificial intelligence is about to make this system far more aggressive and precise.

The Numbers Don't Lie

The scope of this problem is staggering across the American healthcare system:

• Federal settlements for upcoding and improper E/M billing total hundreds of millions, including emergency services violations

• Systems now assign billing codes based on documentation-driven scoring that inflates complexity rather than actual patient needs or resource use

• Real cost differences: Level 1 emergency facility fees average about $150–$200, while Level 5 facility fees often exceed $600 (Medicare facility fees; commercial insurers can pay 2–4x more)

• Share of Level 4–5 ER visits rose markedly over the 2010s—well beyond what patient acuity alone explains

A Nationwide Revenue Enhancement Industry

This isn't isolated to a few bad actors – it's become standard practice across American healthcare. Major health systems in all 50 states now employ coding consultants (also called CDI specialists or revenue integrity teams) whose primary function is maximizing reimbursement from every emergency department encounter. These professionals operate with sophisticated software tools and industry-standard methodologies that have transformed emergency billing from a documentation exercise into a revenue optimization process.

The coding consultant industry itself generates billions annually by helping hospitals "optimize" their emergency department billing, creating an entire ecosystem of companies, training programs, and certification processes dedicated to extracting maximum revenue from patient encounters. Meanwhile, outlier hospitals often face inconsistent enforcement, creating a risk-reward calculation that heavily favors aggressive coding practices.

Perhaps most troubling, certified coding specialists regularly become whistleblowers after witnessing systematic overcharging schemes within their own institutions. Hospital systems routinely receive complaints from their own coding staff about these practices – and consistently ignore them in favor of meeting revenue targets and financial performance metrics.

The Revenue Optimization Playbook

Here's how the modern ER coding enhancement process works: see patient → scan chart after the visit → add documentation to justify higher code → submit higher bill.

The Clinical Encounter: Patient receives legitimate medical care from physicians and nurses following standard protocols.

The Chart Review: Within 24-48 hours, coding specialists review the electronic medical record looking for documentation opportunities.

The Enhancement Process: Using automated rules or manual review, they identify ways to justify higher-level billing codes based on documentation patterns rather than medical necessity.

The Billing Submission: The enhanced codes are submitted to insurance companies, often resulting in much higher reimbursement (2–4x in some cases).

The Human Impact

This isn't just about numbers on spreadsheets. Real patients face real consequences:

Emergency departments now employ dedicated "revenue recovery auditors" whose primary job is resolving complaints from patients who believe they've been overbilled. The fact that these positions exist in significant numbers tells you everything about the scale of this problem.

Having navigated healthcare finance for decades, I've seen how these practices create a vicious cycle: higher coding leads to higher insurance premiums, which leads to more aggressive cost-shifting to patients, which creates more financial pressure on families already dealing with medical crises.

Patients routinely report receiving bills that seem completely disconnected from the complexity of care they received – a simple laceration repair billed at the same level as a heart attack evaluation.

The Industry's Calculated Defense

When confronted with these practices, hospitals typically respond with variations of: "We're simply ensuring accurate documentation and appropriate payment for the complexity of care we provide."

Here's what drives me absolutely crazy about this response.

Yes, accurate payment matters—but the consistent upward drift shows optimization is crowding out clinical reality. If documentation accuracy were the goal, why do coding "enhancements" consistently trend upward? Why don't we see similar efforts to identify over-coding and reduce inappropriate charges?

The entire industry has convinced itself that "optimization" always means "increase." That's not optimization – that's manipulation.

The Sepsis Playbook

This same pattern played out with sepsis coding over the past two decades. When sepsis started paying more, diagnoses skyrocketed. A sepsis code can add roughly five figures to a hospital payment, depending on complications and comorbidities.

The result? What was once a relatively rare diagnosis in medical school became one of the most frequently coded conditions in American hospitals. Now emergency departments are applying this exact same methodology to every patient encounter.

The AI Amplification Threat

Here's where this story takes a terrifying turn: artificial intelligence is about to supercharge this entire system.

AI systems can analyze vast amounts of clinical data in real-time, identifying documentation opportunities that human coders might miss. They can suggest additional questions for physicians to ask, tests to order, and conditions to consider – all optimized for billing enhancement rather than clinical necessity.

The same technology that could revolutionize healthcare by improving diagnosis and treatment is being deployed to extract maximum revenue from every patient encounter.

Having worked extensively with AI implementation in healthcare, I can tell you that these systems will be incredibly sophisticated. AI will prompt the doctor to ask five extra questions that flip your visit from Level 2 to Level 4—without changing your care.

Imagine walking into an ER where an AI system has already analyzed your symptoms and is prompting the physician to ask specific questions designed not to improve your care, but to justify the highest possible billing code.

What Needs to Happen

The solution requires action on multiple fronts:

Regulatory Reform: Establish real-time monitoring systems that flag statistical outliers and impose immediate financial penalties for systematic upcoding.

Industry Accountability: Require public disclosure of emergency department billing pattern audits and implement independent oversight of coding enhancement programs.

Technology Governance: Create strict ethical guidelines preventing AI systems from optimizing clinical documentation for revenue rather than patient care.

Payment System Reform: Transition to bundled emergency department payments that eliminate gaming incentives while maintaining quality care standards.

The Bottom Line

The emergency room has become a profit optimization center disguised as a medical facility. While physicians focus on saving lives, an entire industry has grown up around extracting maximum revenue from those life-saving efforts.

• Coding consultants are now standard in American emergency departments – the people pushing carts through your medical records • Automated systems favor documentation-driven scoring that inflates complexity rather than clinical complexity or actual resource utilization • AI threatens to make these practices invisible and universal – optimizing every clinical interaction for maximum billing • Patients bear the financial burden of an industry optimized for revenue extraction rather than healing

This isn't about a few bad hospitals gaming the system. This is about an entire industry that has normalized the practice of systematically inflating emergency room charges through sophisticated documentation schemes.

The only question is whether we'll address this crisis before AI makes it impossible to detect and unstoppable in its reach.

What's your experience with unexpected emergency room charges? Have you or your organization been impacted by aggressive billing practices? Share your thoughts in the comments.

As a former healthcare CEO and current healthcare AI consultant, I'm committed to exposing practices that prioritize profit over patients. Follow for more insights on healthcare transformation and industry accountability.

#Healthcare #EmergencyMedicine #HealthcareFinance #MedicalBilling #HealthcareTransparency #HealthcareReform #PatientRights #HealthcareLeadership #MedicalCoding #HealthcareInnovation